Saturday, November 20, 2010

Irish Pub Poseurs in Philly

It’s been awhile between posts, loyal readers; it seems that ol’ Paddy doesn’t get out much these days. I’ve picked the low-hanging fruit in my area, so it looks like I need to expand my horizons and plan some road trips. Anyway, I was in old city Philadelphia for a birthday party the other night. The festivities were happening in a dark club with overpriced drinks and lots of neon lights. Not my scene, to say the least. I don’t feel any more hip and sophisticated paying $12 for Jameson. Not 12 year-old or Gold label, by the way, just run-of-the-mill Jameson. I decided to step out and check out some nearby places that call themselves Irish pubs.

I went into The Plough and The Stars on 2nd street. The place looks like someone turned an old bank into a bar and didn’t put much effort into it. The interior was pretty sparse, with some tables and a bar against the wall. The décor was minimal and not remotely Irish. The place looked pretty generic. The bartender was very friendly and rattled off the bar’s (extensive) Irish whiskey selection without missing a beat. It didn’t seem like a bad place to enjoy a cocktail, but The Plough and The Stars is definitely not an Irish pub.

I headed over to Brownie’s, which seemed more promising. It has a big flag hanging out front with a green shamrock emblazoned on it. Inside, the bar has the casual look of a corner sports bar; dark wood bar, pool table, sports memorabilia on the walls. There wasn’t much to designate the place as an Irish pub, no real décor to speak of. The bar selection was pretty weak, with only 4 Irish whiskies on offer. Brownie’s is the kind of so-called Irish pub that bothers me; it’s just a sports bar that tries to become an Irish pub by putting up a few shamrocks. They need to exert more effort in order to be credible.

The bottom line is that neither of these places qualifies as an Irish pub. They both may be perfectly suitable watering holes, but if you seek some good craic, go elsewhere.

Saturday, October 23, 2010

Uisce Beatha: Powers

As I'm sitting here watching Notre Dame take a beating at the hands of Navy, I figure I can post a long overdue rating of my new go-to, everyday Irish whiskey. Powers is a good bridge whiskey for those who are skeptical of Irish whiskey. It is a pot still, though not a pure one like Red Breast, so it has a more full-bodied and muscular taste. Powers is smoother than Jameson, sweet but without being cloying like Bushmills is, and more robust than Tullamore Dew. And since Powers is generally slightly cheaper than the big 3, there's another reason you can turn the Scotch and Bourbon crowd onto it without much financial risk to them.

Powers has a nice, deep gold color, darker than many other Irish selections. The initial smell is like honey-coated alcohol, giving you a simultaneous sense of smoothness and robustness. The taste is smooth and peppery, with a pleasant shot of alcohol throughout the sinuses. Powers lingers in the mouth, with a nice stickiness on the tongue. For one of the cheaper Irish whiskey, Powers gives a lot of bang for the buck. For those who dismiss the Irish drams for being overly light and lacking complexity, Powers is one to try.

Powers is a whiskey that grows on you. At first, I termed it "hair on your chest whiskey" because of the heavier flavor than is usual for Irish whiskey. I used to need ice with Powers back when, the training wheels so to speak. But given enough time and tastings, the "Powers Punch" will become your friend. Now, I take it straight, which I recommend to others, but you can still dash in some water to open it up. Now, if you're coming to Powers from Bushmills or Tullamore Dew, be prepared to get knocked back a step. If you're a Jameson man, Powers will be a nice step up, having all the muscularity without the excessive alcohol burn. And if you're into the pot still taste of Red Breast, Powers will fall nicely into your stride, being sort of a rascally, shanty Irish, pot still cousin to RB. Powers may not be great, but it is very good for what it is. And it's the perfect dram for the upcoming winter.

Paddy's Grade: B

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Paddy's Disappointments

Why am I disappointed? The first reason is painfully obvious to any Notre Dame fans out there. The Irish were out-played by Michigan. Notre Dame came out swinging, easily marching down the field for a score on their first possession. Michigan came right back to tie it up. Then Dayne Crist had to be sidelined for a while. The Irish’s 2 back-up QBs, included Joe Montana’s son Nate, couldn’t make anything happen. Meanwhile, Michigan’s offense picked apart the Irish defense, bringing the score to 21-7 at the half. Crist came back out to retake the lead at the end of the 4th quarter, but Michigan came right back with a game-winning score.

This was a different-looking team from last week. The Irish were firing on all cylinders against Perdue: offense, defense, and special teams. The run game looked like it wouldn’t solely consist of Armando Allen. But Michigan’s defense made the Irish look like a one trick pony; Crist passing to TE Kyle Rudolph was all that seemed to work. The Irish defense wasn’t giving up any long balls to Michigan’s QB, who responded by throwing underneath all day and running for over 200 yards. I’m hoping this isn’t another hot-and-cold year for the Irish; I guess this Saturday’s game against Michigan State will show if the Irish can really jell.

My second disappointment came when Mrs. Paddy and I visited Catherine Rooney’s newly opened second location in Newark, Delaware. I consider Rooney’s Wilmington location to be one of Delaware’s best Irish pubs. The Newark version did not impress me, though. The new place in has the same authentic Irish pub look as the original: dark wood, cabinets adorning the bar, a parlor room. But the craic just wasn’t there. Newark is a college town, and while I expected a college crowd I was still put off at the obnoxious loudness of the bar patrons. Irish pubs are supposed to be fun, laid back places, not gin mills with people screaming at each other for no good reason. The whole staff was young, but I was surprised that the bartender did not give me a blank stare when I asked for a Powers neat. He did put my whiskey in a snifter, an unfortunate habit that too many bartenders have. Snifters are for cognac and other liquors; whiskey goes in a whiskey glass, damn it. The drink was ridiculously over-priced, too. The barkeep either rang it up wrong or management is trying to bleed liquor drinkers dry. The food was okay, about the same quality as the original location. The new location has the same Irish whiskey to Scotch proportion problem as the original location, almost 2-to-1 in favor of Scotch. They can still put Dawlwhinnie on the back bar, but no Red Breast? Let’s get with it, guys.

It was not an overall pleasant experience that we had, but I don’t think it is entirely the fault of the establishment. My opinion is that Rooney’s owners opened the wrong type of place in the wrong location. Irish pubs appeal to a more grown-up and civilized customer base; opening one in a hard-drinking college town is not advisable. The problem is compounded by the fact that Catherine Rooney’s has an established reputation and a loyal following. This new location may just hurt their brand. The owners of Rooney’s would have been better off opening another of their C.R. Hooligans sports bar location in Newark. Hooligans is a more casual place that appeals to a younger, more rowdy crowd. It would have been a perfect fit for Newark, as opposed to them trying to put the round peg of Rooney’s into the square hole of Main Street Newark. The absence of critic made all the difference; it goes to show how vital it is for a pub to have. The original Rooney’s has plenty to go around, which is why I keep going back. The new Rooney’s doesn’t have the critic at all, which is why I’ll probably not go back.

Paddy’s Grade: C-

Questions? Comments? Suggestions? paddythepublican@gmail.com

Thursday, September 9, 2010

The Fighting Irish: Week 1

The Irish got off to a solid start this year versus Perdue. Dayne Crist appears to be a worthy successor to Clausen and Quinn. The ground game looks much improved and the defense looks better than it has in awhile. I know it's just one game and it wasn't exactly a blowout cakewalk (you guys got nailed for a safety? Seriously?) but I'm cautiously getting my hopes up. I'm looking forward to enjoying many a fine dram of Irish whiskey while watching Notre Dame do better than .500.

Inquiring minds may want to know which Irish pub I selected for my Fighting Irish viewing pleasure. Well, I didn't. You see, I knew I was going to probably get a bit loud and rowdy, this being the kick-off game and all. Plus, since the temperature leveled off into the realm of bearability, I was going to be able to partake in copious amounts of Irish whiskey (Tully Dew in this case). I know it sounds strange coming from a committed shanty Irishman, but I didn't want to act like a boor at one of my favored local pubs. I can't stand those guys who scream and holler at the top of their miserable lungs over every down of a game. I like a lively sports bar scene, but I don't need my ears to bleed because the guy next to me is blowing a very loud gasket because his fantasy stats are getting shellacked. I don't want to be that obnoxious, screaming jag-off, at least not in place that I frequent. So, I decided to take in the game at home, where I could bellow and carry on to my heart's content. I'd only be disturbing my neighbors, and we don't talk much anyway. (And probably even less so now, considering all the windows were open in my place while I watched the game). Now, I just have to decide what whiskey I'm going to have as an accompaniment to this Saturday's game versus Michigan. There's a bottle of Paddy on my shelf that's been looking awfully lonely of late. Here's hoping that I'll be toasting to a 2-0 start.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Getting my Irish up with the Phils

With the lengthy heat wave we’ve been experiencing in my area recently, I haven’t been too keen on visiting Irish pubs. As much as I love Irish whiskey, it is not my go-to alcoholic beverage when the heat index is pushing into triple digits. And I’m too much of a shanty mick to order anything but the uisce beatha when I’m in an Irish bar. In short, I haven’t been seeing the inside of too many pubs lately.

I did go to a Philadelphia Phillies game the other day when they hosted the San Francisco Giants (Phils won 9-3). I’m not a baseball fan, but some friends invited Mrs. Paddy and I, and we had a great time. Incidentally, it was also Irish heritage night at the ballpark. Plenty of people were wearing Irish-themed shirts, including the green Phillies t-shirt with a shamrock. There was a school dance troupe performing Irish dancing on top of the home team dugout during one of the breaks. The Phanatic got up there and danced with them, which was very amusing.

Before the game, we did stop in to McFadden’s saloon and restaurant. McFadden’s is a pub with a main location in Philadelphia and is very popular with the early twenties crowd. It usually gets mentioned when one asks about Philly Irish pubs even though I saw nothing in the location where it advertised itself as an Irish pub (and it is definitely not one). McFadden’s claim to local fame is that they employ almost entirely a female bar and service staff of the young, leggy, and busty variety. Now, I’m a red-blooded American male and far be it from me to complain about an establishment that is staffed with attractive women. However, having been a bartender for 10 years, there are certainly some drawbacks to the non-Y chromosome bar staff. First of all, hiring someone just on the basis of looks is a bad idea. In my experience, personality and mixology skill are what makes a good bartender. Being easy on the eyes is certainly an asset, but being hot alone does not seal the deal. Forgive my indelicacy, but if a bartender is an incompetent bitch, her big knockers and sharp cheekbones are not going to make me feel good about getting sub-par service. Now before I hear the howls of protest about my latent sexism, let me say that I don’t have anything against female bartenders. I’ve worked with women who can hold down a busy bar just as well as any guy. My beef is with the d-cup dullards who think that wearing hot shorts and 2 pounds of eye make-up is all that counts when tending bar. I also blame the owners and managers who hire based on bra and waist size rather then drink knowledge and customer service skills. Granted, you can teach drink recipes and proper service, but you can’t teach hotness, I get that. But even my wife’s heart sinks when we sit down at a bar and some blank-faced Barbie comes over to serve us. Call us judgmental, but in that situation, neither my wife nor I are going to risk ordering a dry, in-and-out Gibson. We’ll probably get something red with Jager in it.

So, back to McFadden’s. The bar was busy, but staffed with 5-6 bartenders, none of whom seemed to be working very hard. After about 5 minutes of waiting, one of them saw me and took my order. This girl, aside from having her boobs pushed up practically to her chin, seemed practically comatose. Cocaine is usually the dope of choice for bartenders, but this girl looked like she was nodding off on heroin. No smile, no please or thank you; just an impersonal transaction from someone who likely got her job because of her looks. I don’t think the proprietors of these types of places realize the people they turn off because of their hiring practices. Am I against hiring babe-tastic bartenders? No way. I like gorgeous girls like any guy. But there are 2 problems here. The first I touched on before; hotness without personality or good manners is useless in any service industry. Secondly, female patrons feel left out. Some time back, I was working as a bouncer at a nightclub that employed mostly scantily clad ladies behind the bar. A female patron said to me “this is real nice for the guys but what about us girls?” She had a point. If a bar is set on hiring eye candy staff, then make it a two way street. Sexy guys and girls; make everyone happy, including the bar owner. I’ve heard so many bar owners complain that they need to pull in more female customers but they don’t know how. For starters, how about not having an all female bar staff. I’m sure that most women would like to be served by a charming stud then a pin-up princess.

Okay, enough ranting by me on this point. Oh, by the way, even though it was hot and even though McFadden’s is not actually an Irish pub, I still ordered a Jameson. And this was before I knew it was Irish heritage night. Still a shanty mick after all.

Saturday, July 10, 2010

History of Irish Whiskey Part 3: The Comeback

Irish whiskey was at a very low point in the mid-twentieth century. Ireland was still a largely rural and economically unsophisticated country. Virtually all of the whiskey distilleries had had closed, and many whiskey brands were forced to consolidate just to survive. Major names like Jameson and Bushmills were often the only Irish whiskey available in American bars. The scarcity of Irish whiskey in the USA had resulted in an entire generation that had virtually no contact with uisce beatha. However, just as a confluence of factors caused Irish whiskey’s decline, a number of events would help to bring it back from the brink.

The sixties, seventies, and eighties witnessed their share of historic and groundbreaking events in America. As far as the alcoholic drinks arena was concerned these decades were real low points. People didn’t much care what they drank at bars and restaurants, by and large. Hardly anyone knew to “swirl and sniff” their wine, micro-brew beer was unheard of, and it didn’t matter how many years the scotch was aged. In the nineties, the drinking landscape really began to change for the better. A gourmet culture in food kicked into high gear, ushering in the nascent era of the celebrity chef. Americans wanted good booze to go along with their new taste for good food. Interest in wine, both domestic and international, took off with people learning the basic differences between grape varietals. The craft beer movement started as a very minor business in previous decades, but now began to grab major attention. Micro-brews became popular alternatives to standards like Coors and Budweiser. The spirits world also came along for the ride.

Starting in the 1990s the average American was looking to trade up from the usual liquor offerings. The basic call brands were no longer satisfactory; people wanted more interesting options. The rise of nationally known cocktail historians and celebrity mixologists, like David Wondrich and Tony Abou-Ganim, sparked an interest in quality drinks made with quality ingredients. Bartending became an exciting profession again, not just a dead-end job of popping beer tops and making endless gin-and-tonics. Of course, the phenomenal popularity of the HBO show Sex in the City led to an explosion of Cosmo-sipping young women. The launch of Grey Goose vodka created the trend of premium vodka for the masses. Newly affluent young men were turning to high-end scotch and small batch bourbon. Americans were drinking and drinking well.

As the saying goes, a rising tide lifts all ships, and Irish whiskey was certainly lifted in the rising tide of America’s alcohol renaissance. The drink of kings had been relegated to gathering dust on the back bars of America’s Irish pubs. But Irish whiskey came back in America; drinkers wanted more options at the bar and Irish whiskey was no exception. An expansion of interest in Irish heritage by a newly ascendant Generation X helped fuel the demand in both Irish beer and whiskey. Fortunately, the “Celtic Tiger,” the rip-roaring Irish economy, could satisfy America’s demand for uisce beatha. Ireland turned a major corner in the 1990s, with a modernized economy pulling the country full force into the 20th century. The Irish whiskey business took off as well, with new distilleries being built, old labels being revived, and new brands hitting the marketplace. International spirits behemoth Pernod Ricard bought the Irish Distillers Group in 1988, which included Jameson. Other, similar partnerships put Irish whiskies in the position to gain an unprecedented position in the market.

For those who remember the bad old days, the days when you could barely find anything besides Jameson or Bushmills outside of a major metro market, were thrilled to suddenly have access to so many new brands of Irish. Old standards in Ireland became new players in America; labels like Tullamore Dew, Powers, and Paddy. The Cooley Distillery, the only Irish-owned distillery, has been making its own original, award-winning whiskies for almost two decades now. Irish whiskey is a small segment of the overall American liquor market, but it is growing at a remarkable pace. Fans of uisce beatha are thrilled that it has come back so strongly and we hope that it continues to surge ahead. Just like the Irish people, Irish whiskey has been to the greatest heights, fallen to the worst nadir, only to climb back and impress its warmth and charm on whiskey drinkers the world over. Slainte!


Questions? Comments? Suggestions? paddythepublican@gmail.com

Saturday, July 3, 2010

A Brief History of Irish Whiskey: Part 2, The Decline

At the start of the 20th century, Irish whiskey was riding high. Uisce Beatha was enjoyed the world over by both the common man and the swell set. But just as Irish whiskey was taking its place in the upper echelon of the spirits world, a confluence of events was coming together to bring it crashing down.

Ireland’s hard and violent struggle for independence from Great Britain came to a head in the early 1900’s. Ireland finally achieved its freedom (mostly) from England in 1921. Most of Ireland, 26 out of 32 counties, became an autonomous, free state in December of 1921. The newly founded Republic of Ireland was met with punitive trade sanctions from its former master, England, immediately. Ireland’s export trade, including its whiskey exports, suffered greatly both from England’s reactionary trade policies and its own status as a newly developing country.
The passage of Prohibition in the United States in 1920 had a hugely deleterious effect on the international liquor trade in general, and the Irish whiskey business in particular. One of the biggest world markets for Irish whiskey went dry for 13 years. The sons and daughters of Eire who yearned for a taste of the ol’ uisce beatha in the USA had to content themselves with whatever could be run onto American shores by bootleggers.
Ireland’s economy, as well as its whiskey industry, suffered a series of setbacks throughout the first half of the 20th century. Ireland may have gotten free of British rule, but that also meant that the small, mostly rural country had to make its way in the international business scene with England actively thwarting its economic progress. The Irish whiskey business dropped off significantly; hundreds of distilleries closed, and only a few survived the culling.
The economic hardship of Ireland led to Irish whiskey becoming severely marginalized in what used to be its largest export market, the USA. After decades of hardship: Prohibition, the Great Depression, World War 2, Americans were ready to live the good life. After the end of WW2, Americans indeed lived it up, sparking a tremendous period of economic growth and prosperity. The booze business boomed after years of lean times. But Irish whiskey was left on the sidelines as Americans took to homemade Bourbon, easily accessible Canadian whiskey, and the Scotch that they picked up a taste for as GIs in the England. Whiskey was big in mid-20th century America, everything but Irish whiskey, anyway. Names like: Jack Daniels, Canadian Club, and Johnny Walker became the standard whiskey calls at bars across America, while names like Jameson and Powers were lucky to be an afterthought. A nation with millions of Irish immigrants and children of Irish immigrants could hardly get their hands of the whiskey of their ancestry.
Every type of alcoholic beverage had its shining moment in America at some point during the post WW2 era. Beer, wine, vodka, rum, scotch, bourbon, gin, and tequila all had their moments in the sun sometime between 1950 and 1990. But Irish whiskey was left out of the party. While choices abounded for enthusiasts of, say, Italian wine or Scotch, Irish whiskey was basically a choice between Jameson or Bushmills for most of the later 1900s. Getting a good dram of uisce beatha in the USA prior to 2000 required knowledge, patience, and dedication. But the Irish are not only used to hardship, they thrive on it, so it was only a matter of time before the many curses that plagued that Irish whiskey business were lifted. Irish Whiskey followed the script for Celtic existence; get beaten to a pulp and pushed to within an inch of extinction before roaring back and becoming everyone’s favorite underdog hero.

Question? Comments? Suggestions? paddythepublican@gmail.com